Essay Preview: Who gets trust vs. who earns it?
De-personalization via data is a best practice
About a month ago my essay for this newsletter used the episode Earshot as its inspiration, and I talked about subtext vs. text. In past writings and talks, I’ve articulated the lesson from that episode a little differently. I’ve said that the main lesson from Earshot is that “it’s not always about you.” We are the main character in our story, but not in everyone else’s and sometimes stuff happens, and if we can de-personalize the behaviors of others, if we can start by realizing it’s not about us, it’s about them, it can be the foundation for more empathy and less anxiety.
In a business context I’ve also extended this to say that data help you de-personalize decision-making when trying to mediate between differing views on what to do, which path to follow. This was standard operating procedure at BlogHer. When my co-founders, Lisa, Jory, and I were in decision-making mode, we were dedicated to bringing the data to support our points of view.
I've given many talks where I talk about how our ability to have these difficult conversations without personalizing the opinions or outcomes we ended up with as one of the reasons that we were able to stay as co-founders running the company together for so many years.
My radical(?) opinion: Sometimes my gut instinct IS data!
Signposting and sharing
💻 Next week’s newsletter: Going into week three for Buffy Season 4 and Angel Season 1. Season 4 of Buffy introduces two characters I hate the most in the Buffyverse, and not for any supernatural Big Bad actions. They’re both just dicks. You’ll see…
🛠️ My Tinkering Thursday video [16 mins.] this week shares the first step in a 3-step workflow I built to balance staying informed on the topics I care most about with avoiding information (and therefore emotional) overload. If you’re like me and have tons of open browser tabs or a list of to-be-read items that seems overwhelming, maybe collected in a couple of different places (I had Safari tabs groups and a Notion database) then the steps I took to consolidate all my open links everywhere into one organized and categorized Reading List in a Google Sheet will be of interest to you. (You could also build it in Notion or even in an Excel spreadsheet). In just a couple of months I’ve gotten a starting list of more than 200 (I know, I know) links I hadn’t touched down to only 20. The next two steps were about how to keep adding to the Reading List with new items of interest and how to integrate items from the List into a daily briefing workflow, so I could work my way through them methodically and consistently. Hope it’s helpful, let me know if you ever want more details on how I constructed these tools I’ve made for myself, so you can do it in a way that works for your needs.
📺 Emotional Support TV: One of my emotional support TV shows is back, the Great British Bake-Off. If you do nothing else, watch the first two episodes, so you can see a little speech by contestant Danni. Danni is what would’ve been called a “bit of an odd duck” in years past, and now, although I don’t think they said it specifically, she definitely seems neurodiverse. In Episode 2 she makes a little speech about what it was like to be in the tent with the other wildly diverse contestants. How they supported and loved one another, and how she discovered she could, in fact, make friends. And honestly, it made me teary. I tried to find video of it, but the only links I found were buried in British tabloid-y websites filled with disruptive ads and AI voiceovers. No thank you. Just go to Netflix and join the GBBO bandwagon.
🎶 I have my next official musical obsession. Her name is Rosalia: You may have heard about all the controversy over SNL’s host last week. Ignore him, F that guy, but go find the clips of Rosalia’s performances from that episode. I was already aware of her…my s.o. saved a performance of hers he saw on TV because she sings in Spanish, and he wanted to see if I could understand her lyrics. That performance was compelling, so I kind of had her bookmarked in my mind, but didn’t follow up. After watching her two performances on SNL, I went and bought all four of her solo albums, the most recent entitled Lux. If you know me, you will know how obsessed I am because of this statement: She is this generation’s Kate Bush. BAM!!! WHAT??? I’m serious. The voice, the melodies, the emotion, the arrangements, the theatricality. I’m going to share both videos, so you don’t even have to go find them. WATCH.
My daily tarot card:

Today I drew The Empress, a Major Arcana card, early in the Major Arcana journey. The Empress is a card full of feminine energy and creativity and connection to the natural world’s cycle of birth and rebirth. In this Buffy tarot deck, the Empress is represented by Drusilla. In life Drusilla was generous and pure of heart. She was driven mad when she became undead, but somewhere underneath the madness she still wanted to grow a garden and take care of creepy dolls. So, spooky, yes, but still Empress energy. This card is a prompt to fan whatever spark of creative energy I’m feeing and fan that it into a flame of abundance. I’ve been experimenting with an actual content strategy around this newsletter including consistent video content (which I’ve never really done before). I’m mid-experiment. I decided I can review the effort, the results, and how much FUN I’m having at the end of the year and scrap it or continue, no harm no foul. All the cards I’ve been drawing have been telling me that whatever the actual result of the experiment, getting off my butt to conduct the experiment in the first place was important.
A card pull or full reading can help make a specific decision. Or can set the tone for your week. Either way, options are here, my Buffy deck and I are at your service! https://calendly.com/elisacp
Out in the world this week:
As I mentioned last week, I recently recorded guest spots on a half dozen podcasts, in quick succession! So, all six are listed here, and I’m featuring one per week in depth.
Feature #4: Flipped Story with David Gadarian: Flipping Luck, Timing and Unplanned Leaps with Elisa Camahort Page
David is a marketer who is intrigued by what happens when people flip the script. I like that he uses the language of “turning blocks into breakthroughs” (rather than saying “busting through blocks” or some other Hulk Smash type language). Like a true marketer, David is really good at turns of phrase. I love his description below about what I’ve leaned into throughout my career.
“Most career advice tells you to pick a lane, make a 10-year plan, and never look back On this episode of The Flipped Story, David Gadarian sits down with Elisa Camahort Page (co-founder of BlogHer & Optionality, author of Road Map for Revolutionaries) to discuss what happens when you throw out the blueprint and lean into timing, luck, and unplanned leaps.”
Here’s a quick excerpt on the topic of changing my entire mind about what I wanted to do with my life at the age of 25, and how it was a leap, for sure, but taught me so much:
Full interview here:
Already featured:
1. The Nightly from Hatch: Why Buffy Still Saves Us All
2. Humans Behind the Tech from Old St Labs, with Rob Woodhead: From Theatre to Tech to Scaling BlogHer (and Beyond)
3. Gina Gardiner & Friends: Your Brain is Your Oldest Asset (and Probably Your Least Examined)
To be featured in upcoming newsletters
1. The Impossible Puzzles podcast with Mike Merkur: Episode 242 with Elisa Camahort Page (I get a little spicy with this one.)
2. The Gut + Science podcast with Nikki Gregory: Stop selling AI as efficiency, start leading it as human growth
BONUS: If you’re a woman in tech, you likely heard that AnitaB.org canceled its storied Grace Hopper Celebration conference this week…two weeks before the event. I have a longtime connection to the org. BlogHer won its Social Impact Award almost 20 years ago, and I subsequently served on their board of advisors, as chair of the selection committee for that award for several years, and on the committee that helped them launch their first entrepreneurism-focused content track. That being said, I haven’t been actively involved in quite a number of years. Since before they changed their name, trading, and CEO. But I do know a thing or two about running large-scale events, so this cancellation two weeks out absolutely shocked me. (And yes, made me sad.) I had a few things to say about it:
FULL ESSAY: Who gets trust vs. who earns it?
De-personalization via data is a best practice
About a month ago my essay for this newsletter used the episode Earshot as its inspiration, and I talked about subtext vs. text. In past writings and talks, I’ve articulated the lesson from that episode a little differently. I’ve said that the main lesson from Earshot is that “it’s not always about you.” We are the main character in our story, but not in everyone else’s and sometimes stuff happens, and if we can de-personalize the behaviors of others, if we can start by realizing it’s not about us, it’s about them, it can be the foundation for more empathy and less anxiety.
In a business context I’ve also extended this to say that data help you de-personalize decision-making when trying to mediate between differing views on what to do, which path to follow. This was standard operating procedure at BlogHer. When my co-founders, Lisa, Jory, and I were in decision-making mode, we were dedicated to bringing the data to support our points of view.
I've given many talks where I talk about how our ability to have these difficult conversations without personalizing the opinions or outcomes we ended up with as one of the reasons that we were able to stay as co-founders running the company together for so many years.
My radical(?) opinion): Sometimes my gut instinct IS data!
But here's the part where I make a deep, dark confession. Sometimes this approach bugged me. Okay, in year one, in year two, in year three, fine, bring all the data, as much as you possibly have. (Although, when you're doing something that hasn't been done, a lot of times it's hard to come up with data that's not purely speculative.)
But in year seven, year eight, there was part of me that just wanted to say, “Haven't we been doing this long enough that when I say, ‘I really think this is the way to go, I have a gut feeling about this,’ that we could all understand that a gut feeling doesn't mean pure instinct? It's instinct backed up by years of experience and observational habit.” Couldn't we just say, "Okay, yeah, let's try it." And sure, let’s decide what we'll do in 30 days, or 60 days, or 90 days if the gut feeling isn't right. I wondered, even if you have a process, and process is good, don’t you ever prove that your opinion IS data, based on how you've come through in the past?
There, I have never said that out loud before.
10 years later the same episode triggers new reactions
I got triggered watching this week's episodes, because there are various times throughout the entire show where Buffy is doubted by or questioned by her Scooby Gang, and she has done so much throughout the seasons of this show. She has saved the world a lot.
Yet it seems like at the drop of a hat, they're willing to say, "What's wrong with Buffy? We need to second-guess what she's telling us.” Rather than saying, "Okay, say more. Tell us why you feel that way." Usually? She’s right; they’re not, and they lost precious time doubting her.
10 years ago, this wasn’t where my mind went watching these same episodes. Our data-driven entrepreneurial processes were still too close. But these many years later, now I ask questions like when have you earned someone's trust? And what does that trust have to look like?
Trust was really at the heart of both the "Buffy" and "Angel" episodes I watched this week. In the "Buffy" episode, despite her years of being the hero and being the leader, she was second-guessed in a heartbeat by her closest friends. In the "Angel" episode, Angel asks a stranger who has every reason not to trust him to just trust him, and after the tiniest bit of evidence that "Oh, yeah, maybe he's trustworthy," they decide to throw their lot in with him, that that was the best choice they had in the moment.
Angel: "We should be sharing information."
Kate: "That’s not possible."
Angel: "All I need is 5 minutes. You think I’m your man after that, arrest me. Meet me at the bar at 7:00."
Kate: "Sure, that’s actually on my to-do list for this week: walk into a serial killer’s trap."
Angel: "Look, I don’t care if you come armed, wired, and covered by sharpshooters. Do what ever it takes so you feel secure... I can help you Kate, but your just going to have to trust me."
And she does.
How it’s about gender
Maybe everything that's been happening around gender dynamics in the last few weeks put this contrast in stark relief (e.g. the Cornell case and the cancellation of the Grace Hopper celebration). The fact that Buffy is a woman and Angel a man was not lost on me in these two different reactions to someone asking to be trusted.
In its own way, it was a microcosm of every established fact we have about how men and women face different reactions in the workplace. In this case, there actually are data to back this up. In investor meetings, men are asked questions about potential. Women are asked questions about prevention. And prevention discussions result in lower fundraising. You do the math.
When being considered for advancement, men are identified for their potential and encouraged to explore it. Women are judged by their experience and asked to justify why they should be trusted to do anything more.
My personal experience on that last point is that women doing a great job are told they’re too valuable to move up, whereas it’s expected that men doing a great job are going to require being moved up. It’s me in my last corporate tech job: I was told I was too important at my current job to move up.
You can even see it in the gender trends on jobs and associated pay. When a job is perceived to be primarily a job of women, the pay goes down. There are many data points about gender dynamics and how they affect pay, how they affect perception, how they affect job reviews.
New realizations are a result of new context
I can assure you I did not think of the allocation of trust when needed, nor the gender dynamics behind it, any of the previous times I’ve watched Buffy. I am enjoying this re-watch and this #BuffyLifeLessons project so much because of these changes in my own reaction to what I’m watching. This re-watch has been the opposite of mindless scrolling for me. It’s mindful absorption of not just the Lessons themselves, but how my context changes, how my knowledge evolves, all of which makes the Lessons change.
While I still believe that de-personalizing business decisions, giving the benefit of the doubt, having empathy for those on the other side of the negotiation is the right call, I think there’s a whole new lesson I’m appreciating for the first time this time around.
It’s not just about who you trust and interrogating why you trust who you trust. It’s who is trusting you? And what is your course of action if you are not being trusted at the level you deserve?
For me, after realizing I wasn’t going to be moved up despite being a star (and a workhorse) and subsequently suffering reporting to a series of less competent men, I realized nothing was going to change and moved myself up by moving along. Moving to what wasn’t clear when I made that move. Less than two years later, I co-founded BlogHer. I am a big fan of making leaps and then making them work. If you’ve been the person who needs every step planned before you take them, you might want to start experimenting with a different approach and take a step that forces you to then make a plan!
I’m curious if you’ve watched anything you loved years later and derived a totally different lesson or even feeling from it. Anything come to mind?
Which Buffy and Angel episodes informed this essay?
I watched Buffy Season 4, episode 2 (Living Conditions recap) and Angel Season 1, episode 2 (Lonely Hearts recap). I’ll be watching the shows each week as they aired 27 years ago. It should be interesting to see if they continue to feel like these two Buffyverse shows were working from the same playbook week by week.
The core #BuffyLifeLesson in Living Conditions is that everyone wants the chance to find themselves. But finding yourself at the expense of someone else is demonic. Also: If someone has shown you who they are, believe them! (As the wise Maya Angelou always reminded us.).
The core #AngelLesson in Lonely Hearts is about the tension that exists because we humans are wired to need connection, but often don’t trust that we can trust humans. And for women, the baggage and layers and subtext are paralyzing!
I’m here every week, using pop culture (and Buffy the Vampire Slayer right now) as a jumping off point for everything I’m thinking about professional leadership, personal development, political philosophy, and pop culture. I would love you to join me by subscribing. And I would love you to share the link with other nerds like us!
FINAL WORDS
Willow: "So Buffy was right all along. Later on, big remorse."



